OSN-E Review Form
=====================================================================

Title: 
Author(s):

Reviewer: 
Date reviewed:

==*== Overall merit
(select one by putting "x" in the brackets)

   [ ] 1. Bad
   [ ] 2. Satisfactory
   [ ] 3. Reasonably good
   [ ] 4. Excellent

==== Reviewer expertise
(select one by putting "x" in the brackets)

   [ ] 1. No familiarity
   [ ] 2. Some familiarity
   [ ] 3. Knowledgeable
   [ ] 4. Expert

==== Paper Summary ====
(write 1-2 paragraphs, no GenAI)


==== Comments for Author(s) ====
(write positive and critical remarks, as short paragraphs or bullet lists)


==== Comments for Course Leader ====
(optional; any notes on this paper not to be shared with its author(s))